Compare energy efficiency measures and their utility costs

IntermediateAbout 90 minutesEP3 3.0

A measure that cuts energy use does not always cut the utility bill. This tutorial builds a small office with the Model Wizard, adds an electricity tariff with demand charges and a gas tariff, and then sets up wall and roof insulation, better windows, lower lighting power, a heat pump system and a different electricity rate as Energy Efficiency Measures (EEMs). One batch run compares them. The results viewer shows energy and annual cost side by side, and Disaggregation splits the combined result into the share each measure contributes to energy and to cost.

All tariff numbers in this tutorial are illustrative. Use your utility’s published rate schedule for a real project.

What you need

  • EP3 3.0 with EnergyPlus 26.2 installed.
  • The starting model, small-office-start.ep3, or follow the first section to build it yourself. The finished model is small-office-eems-and-costs.ep3 if you want to compare your work with it.
  • An EnergyPlus weather file. The screenshots use USA_IL_Chicago-OHare.Intl.AP.725300_TMY3.epw (Chicago O’Hare, climate zone 5A). Download it from https://energyplus.net/weather.
  • About 90 minutes. The runs take about a minute for the first batch and a few minutes for the 16 disaggregation runs.
  • The screenshots use SI units (m, °C, kWh).

Build the starting model with the Model Wizard

The Model Wizard opens when EP3 starts without a file, and each time you choose File > New.

  1. On Model Settings, choose SI (m, °C) for Units, click Select Weather File and choose your weather file. Leave Select Climate Zone at Automatic (from weather file).

The Model Settings tab with SI units, EnergyPlus 26.2 and the Chicago O’Hare weather file.

  1. On Internal Loads, type Office in the filter, expand EP3 Library > Internal Loads > Space-by-Space Occupancy Types and tick Office - Open Plan.

The Internal Loads tab with one load selected.

  1. On Constructions, type CZ5 NonResidential in the filter, then tick the NonResidential group under ASHRAE 90.1-2022 > CZ5. The tab shows 13 constructions selected. The filter also lists the Appendix G Baseline and eQuest groups with the same names, so check the group’s parent in the list.

The Constructions tab with 13 constructions selected.

  1. Leave Service Hot Water empty.
  2. On HVAC Systems, expand EP3 Library > Systems > HVAC and SWH Systems and tick PSZ-AC and PSZ-HP. These are the packaged single-zone air conditioner (PSZ-AC), with a gas furnace, and the packaged single-zone heat pump (PSZ-HP). Each system becomes an EEM, so the model starts with two HVAC alternatives.

The HVAC Systems tab with PSZ-AC and PSZ-HP ticked.

  1. On Building Geometry, choose Let EP3 draw a rectangular building for me and enter Building Width 30, Building Depth 20, Number of Floors 2 and Floor to Floor Height 3.5. Leave Window to Wall Ratio at 30. Type Office - Open Plan in Perimeter Space Type and in Core Space Type.

The Building Geometry tab with a 30 by 20 m, two-floor building and Office - Open Plan for the perimeter and core spaces.

  1. Click Execute Wizard. The status bar reads “Templates: 3 file(s), 70 object(s) added, 2 EEM(s). Building drawn.” The building has two floors, each with a perimeter ring and a core, for 10 Spaces and 8 windows in all.

Use the Fixed Fenestration construction for windows

The windows the Wizard draws take the Glazing default construction, which starts as the entrance-door glazing. Switch it to the fixed-window construction so that the window measure later applies to these windows.

  1. Click Edit input fields for objects with no physical representation in the top toolbar to open the main object dialog. In Column 1, turn off the switch beside the filter box so every object type is listed, type Default Constr in the filter and click Default Constructions.
  2. With Global in the EEM dropdown at the top, set Glazing to CZ5 NonResidential Fixed Fenestration Construction.

The Default Constructions page with Glazing set to the CZ5 NonResidential Fixed Fenestration Construction.

Tip: Drag the corner of the main object dialog to make it larger. The tariff panels and EEM pages are easier to read at about 1000 pixels wide.

Save the model.

Add the utility tariffs

The Wizard does not create tariffs, and a model without one reports no energy cost. Tariffs are in the Economics group in Column 1. Add them with Global active so every EEM starts with the same rates.

Electricity with demand charges

  1. In the main object dialog filter, type Tariff and click UtilityCost:Tariff, then click Add Object.
  2. In Add Tariff, leave Meter at Electricity, type Electric Demand Rate for Tariff Name, leave Group Name blank and click Add Tariff.

The Add Tariff form, here for a second tariff on the gas meter, with the warning that EnergyPlus bills only the lowest-cost tariff on a meter.

  1. In the tariff’s fields in Column 3, type 35 in Monthly Charge or Variable Name, then click another field so the value is kept. This is a fixed monthly service charge in dollars.
  2. Under Energy Charges (billed on total energy use), click + Add Flat Rate. Type Energy Charge for Charge Name, 0.11 for Rate ($ per kWh) and click Add.

The Add Flat Rate form with an energy charge of 0.11 dollars per kWh.

  1. Under Demand Charges (billed on peak demand), click + Add Tiered / Block Rate. Type Demand Charge for Charge Name, set Number of Tiers to 2, enter 50 for Tier 1 size and 8 for Tier 1 rate ($/kW), and enter 12 for Tier 2 rate ($/kW). Tier 2 size stays remaining. Click Add.

The Add Tiered / Block Rate form: the first 50 kW at 8 dollars per kW and the remaining demand at 12 dollars per kW.

The panel now lists EnergyCharge - $0.11 per kWh and DemandCharge - 50 @ $8.00/kW, remaining @ $12.00/kW. Each row has Edit, Remove and a power button that switches the charge on or off per EEM.

The Electric Demand Rate tariff: a 35 dollar monthly charge, the energy charge and the two-tier demand charge.

Natural gas

  1. Click Add Object, choose Natural Gas for Meter, type Gas Rate and click Add Tariff.
  2. Set Conversion Factor Choice to Therm so the rate is per therm. In an SI model the default is MJ.
  3. Type 20 in Monthly Charge or Variable Name and click another field.
  4. Under Energy Charges, click + Add Flat Rate. Type Gas Charge for Charge Name and 0.90 for Rate, and click Add.

The Gas Rate tariff with a 20 dollar monthly charge and a gas charge of 0.90 dollars per therm.

Note: EnergyPlus applies one tariff per meter: when several tariffs bill the same meter in one run, only the lowest-cost qualifying tariff is billed. Keep one tariff per meter in each EEM, as this tutorial does.

Build the measures as EEMs

The two HVAC systems already exist as EEMs named PSZ-AC and PSZ-HP. PSZ-AC is the baseline. The other measures build on it. An EEM stores only what it changes.

Create the EEMs

  1. In the main object dialog, type Model Alt in the filter and click Model Alternatives (EEMs).
  2. Click Add Object. Type Wall and Roof Insulation in the name box at the top of the page and press Enter.
  3. Set EEM Include Type to Single EEM (follow one parent’s chain) and EEM to Include to PSZ-AC. The Current EEM Chain reads PSZ-AC → Global.
  4. Repeat for three more EEMs, each built on PSZ-AC: Better Windows, Lower Lighting Power and Energy-Only Electric Rate.

Wall and Roof Insulation

  1. In the EEM dropdown in the top toolbar, choose Wall and Roof Insulation. Every value you enter now goes into this EEM.
  2. In the object dialog, find Material:NoMass and open CZ5 NonResidential Ext Wall Construction Insulation. Fields with nothing stored in the active EEM show the inherited value on a rose background. Set Thermal Resistance to 4.4 (the original is 3.25 m²·K/W).

The wall insulation material edited in the Wall and Roof Insulation EEM, with a thermal resistance of 4.4.

  1. Open CZ5 NonResidential Roof Construction Insulation and set Thermal Resistance to 7.04 (the original is 5.19).

Open Model Alternatives (EEMs) and select Wall and Roof Insulation. Its page lists only the two values stored in this EEM, under Objects with Custom Values in this EEM.

The Wall and Roof Insulation EEM page: a single EEM built on PSZ-AC with two thermal resistance values stored.

Better Windows

  1. Choose Better Windows in the EEM dropdown.
  2. Open WindowMaterial:SimpleGlazingSystem and select NonResidential Fixed Fenestration Glazing. Set U-Factor to 1.4 (the original is 2.04) and Solar Heat Gain Coefficient to 0.3 (the original is 0.38).

The Better Windows EEM page with the fixed glazing’s U-Factor and Solar Heat Gain Coefficient stored in the EEM.

Lower Lighting Power

  1. Choose Lower Lighting Power in the EEM dropdown.
  2. Open SpaceType, select Office - Open Plan, open its Lights tab and set Watts per Floor Area to 4.5 (the original is 6.03 W/m²).

The Lights tab of the Office - Open Plan Space Type with 4.5 watts per square metre stored in the Lower Lighting Power EEM.

Energy-Only Electric Rate: switch a tariff off in an EEM

This EEM keeps the building as it is and changes only the electricity rate: a plan with no demand charge and a higher energy price.

  1. Choose Energy-Only Electric Rate in the EEM dropdown.
  2. Open UtilityCost:Tariff and click Add Object. Choose Electricity, type Energy-Only Rate and click Add Tariff. A tariff created while an EEM is active is on only in that EEM.

Tip: If the tariff is named Electricity Tariff, rename it in the name box at the top of its panel and press Enter.

  1. Type 35 in Monthly Charge or Variable Name and click another field.
  2. Under Energy Charges, click + Add Flat Rate and add a charge with a Rate of 0.145. Charge names must be unique across the model, so this charge is named EnergyCharge2.

The Energy-Only Rate tariff in the Energy-Only Electric Rate EEM: a 35 dollar monthly charge and an energy charge of 0.145 dollars per kWh, with the note that two tariffs bill the same meter.

  1. Select Electric Demand Rate in Column 2.
  2. Click the power button beside Tariff is on in this EEM. The line now reads Tariff is off in this EEM: it and its charges are left out of the export. The tariff’s name turns red in Column 2 because it is off in the active EEM. Both tariffs stay in the model, and only one bills the electricity meter in each EEM.

The Electric Demand Rate tariff switched off in the Energy-Only Electric Rate EEM.

Open Model Alternatives (EEMs) and select Energy-Only Electric Rate to see the new tariff, its charge and its settings listed as the EEM’s custom values.

The Energy-Only Electric Rate EEM page: the new tariff and its energy charge stored as custom values in the EEM.

All Measures

  1. Choose Global in the EEM dropdown.
  2. In Model Alternatives (EEMs), click Add Object and name the EEM All Measures.
  3. Leave EEM Include Type at Multiple EEMs (ordered list, first has priority) and tick Wall and Roof Insulation, Better Windows, Lower Lighting Power and PSZ-HP. The Current EEM Chain lists them above Global.

A Multiple EEMs entry takes only what each listed EEM stores. PSZ-HP supplies the heat pump system, so PSZ-AC stays unticked. The rate EEM is left out so that the combined result shows only the building and system changes.

The All Measures EEM built on four measures with Multiple EEMs.

Save the model.

Run the EEMs together

  1. Click Simulate in the top toolbar.
  2. Untick Global, and tick PSZ-AC, PSZ-HP, Wall and Roof Insulation, Better Windows, Lower Lighting Power, Energy-Only Electric Rate and All Measures. The heading reads “7 runs chosen”.
  3. Click Simulate and choose a folder for the run files.

The Simulate / Export dialog with seven EEMs ticked, and the run table below showing each run as Completed.

The seven runs finish within about a minute. The two heat pump runs report four or more severe warnings from EnergyPlus about the cooling coil’s outlet air temperature in low-load hours. These warnings do not stop the runs.

Note: Click Validate on the top toolbar before a run to catch problems with the model itself. The Wizard’s model passes with no issues.

Compare energy and cost in the results viewer

Click View Results. The viewer loads every run in the folder and opens on EnergyPlus Files.

Annual cost

  1. Click Select Reports. Expand Economics Results Summary Report, tick Annual Cost and Tariff Summary, and click Update.

The Select Reports to View dialog with Annual Cost and Tariff Summary ticked under Economics Results Summary Report.

  1. Open the Economics Results Summary Report tab. The Annual Cost table has a column group per run, with each fuel and the total. The table is wide: scroll sideways, or tick Bar or Stacked Bar under the table title to chart a column. The Tariff Summary below it shows which tariff was Selected for each run.

The Annual Cost table with the electricity, natural gas and total cost for each run.

With these illustrative tariffs and weather, the runs report:

EEM Site energy (kWh/yr) Annual cost ($)
PSZ-AC (baseline) 162,939 14,384
Wall and Roof Insulation 157,024 14,132
Better Windows 155,055 13,898
Lower Lighting Power 159,458 13,581
Energy-Only Electric Rate 162,939 14,204
PSZ-HP 159,727 24,712
All Measures 144,722 22,391

Your totals can differ slightly with another weather file or EnergyPlus version.

Three results stand out.

  • Energy-Only Electric Rate uses exactly the baseline’s energy and costs $180 less. The building is unchanged; dropping the demand charge saves more than the higher energy price adds.
  • The envelope and lighting measures each lower both energy and cost.
  • PSZ-HP uses about 2 percent less site energy than the baseline and costs about $10,300 more. The heat pump replaces gas at $0.90 per therm with electricity at $0.11 per kWh plus a demand charge, and the winter morning peak in Chicago is billed at $12 per kW.

Parallel coordinates

The Parallel Coordinates tab draws one line per run across axes for the inputs that differ between the EEMs, then the results.

  1. Click « Axes & Runs. Click an axis in the list to show or hide it. Hide the axes you do not need, then click Hide Unchecked. This tutorial keeps the EEM, window, lighting, wall and roof insulation, HVAC System and tariff axes, plus Total Electricity, Total Natural Gas, Site EUI (site energy use intensity) and Total Energy Cost.
  2. Set Title Size to Small and Title Wrap to Compact so the titles fit.

The input side of the Parallel Coordinates tab: the EEM axis followed by the window, lighting, insulation and HVAC System inputs, one line per run.

  1. Scroll the chart to the right to reach the result axes. The heat pump run’s line climbs to the top of Total Energy Cost while its Site EUI line goes down.

The result axes: Total Natural Gas, Site EUI and Total Energy Cost for the seven runs.

Hover over a line to see the run’s name and its value on every axis. Drag along an axis to select a range: runs outside it fade. Clear Selections removes the selection.

Split the combined result with Disaggregation

All Measures combines four changes, and the table above does not show what each contributes. Disaggregation runs combinations of the changes and reports each one’s share of the difference, interactions included.

  1. Open Model Alternatives (EEMs), select All Measures and click the Disaggregation tab.
  2. Set Starting EEM to PSZ-AC. EP3 lists five change groups: the HVAC system, the wall insulation, the roof insulation, the windows, and the lighting power.
  3. Tick the wall and roof insulation groups and click Combine selected (2). This leaves four groups.
  4. Rename the groups, with Rename or by typing in each group’s name: Heat pump system, Wall and roof insulation, Better windows and Lower lighting power.

The Disaggregation tab of All Measures, with PSZ-AC as the Starting EEM, four change groups, and Every combination chosen for 16 runs.

  1. Leave Run Set at Every combination (16 runs), scroll to Simulation Runs and click Simulate (16 selected). EP3 asks for confirmation before running more than eight, so click Simulate again, then choose a folder. The runs go in a subfolder named PSZ-AC to All Measures.
  2. When they finish, click View Results. The Disaggregation tab shows the table and a stacked bar. With Metric set to Site energy, the four measures account for the 18,217 kWh/yr difference like this:

The Disaggregation tab with Site energy as the metric: shares of 11, 28, 39 and 22 percent for the heat pump, insulation, windows and lighting.

  1. Change Metric to Utility cost. The total difference is now +$8,007 a year, and the heat pump group accounts for +$9,944 of it. The other three groups lower the bill by $493, $740 and $704.

The Disaggregation tab with Utility cost as the metric: the heat pump system adds 9,944 dollars a year, the other three measures subtract 493, 740 and 704.

The Alone column is a group’s effect without the others, and Last in is its effect when added to a model that already has the other three. The two differ because the changes interact, and the share combines them: the heat pump system saves 3,212 kWh alone but only 877 kWh after the envelope and lighting measures have cut the loads.

Important: Run Every combination to get the Share column. One at a time and All but one give only Alone and Last in.

Next steps

  • Read Energy Efficiency Measures (EEMs) for branching EEMs, which run several values of one change, and for HVAC System EEMs.
  • Read Utility Costs for time-of-use and seasonal rates, demand ratchets and eligibility rules, and for how EnergyPlus picks one tariff per meter.
  • Read Viewing and Interpreting Results for the other report tabs and the time-series viewer.
  • Read Running Simulations for run folders, run names and parallel runs.
  • Read The EP3 AI Assistant: Atlas can add tariffs, charges and tiers, and switch a tariff or any of its charges on or off in an EEM.

More tutorials · Book a demo · Ask about training

EP3 for Mac

Tell us you'd use it on a Mac. It helps us decide what to build next, and we'll email you when it's ready.

Which computers would you run it on?
Mac is included because you asked about EP3 for Mac
Send me occasional news about EP3 software

Sending…

Thanks!

We've noted that you'd like EP3 on a Mac. Our reply is on its way to : check your inbox, and your spam folder if it isn't there in a few minutes.